|Saved By the Gel Waterproof Eyeliner in "Gold Star"|
The gel liner comes in a simple glass jar. The included brush has a bend liner end and a straight liner end; both are fine and tapered. The brush works fairly wear at creating fine lines and winged tips.
|Saved By the Gel Waterproof Eyeliner in "Blackboard"|
Blackstar is a simple dark black liner. The formulation is smooth and pigmented; it applies very nicely and sets in a flash. Gold Star, on the other hand, is a beautiful metallic gold. The color is also very opaque as well.
In terms of wear, I had no problem with Gold Star, the color stays nicely. Even after the whole day, there was only a bit of creasing. The wear of Blackstar, on the other hand, was a bit disappointing. After two or so hours I noticed smudging, especially in the inner corner. Additionally, the formulation is definitely not a waterproof.
|Left: Gold Star; Right: Blackboard|
Both liners apply beautifully and smoothly. Gold Star lasts nicely and gives the eyes a subtle pop of color. Blackboard is an intense black, but the formulation is prone to smudging.