When you see the Photo Angle Pure Pigment Gel Liner, the Benefit Push Up Liner comes right to mind as they both feature a twist up dispenser and a silicone tip with a thin slit that allows the gel liner to come out. In fact, in terms of packaging the two are really no different. The real difference lies in the formulation.
 |
| The silicone tip comes with a stop to prevent the formulation from drying; it can be removed upon first use. |
Admittedly one of the most pigmented and long-lasting gel formulation I've ever tried, the formulation of this eyeliner is way too dry (even drier than the Benefit Push Up Liner). As a result, it was incredibly difficult to attain precise and smooth lines on the lid. Within seconds, the gel stiffens and instead of gliding smoothly across the lid, it skips and drags. I in fact had to apply in a stamping motion. The method works but it compromises precision. Also once it's on the lid, the product feels drying. I have fairly wrinkly upper lids and as a result the product feels stiff and clingy.
As I said before, the formulation is indeed very long lasting. It is smudge, water, and oil proof. It's best removed with a non-oil based remover as an oil formulation will partly dissolve the product and cause it to smudge/stain everywhere.
Also as I said before about these silicone tips, they are really just not my cup of tea. I struggle with creating a nice line because it's not stiff enough, especially when paired with such a thick formulation.
 |
| The product swatches decently on smooth skin but on eyelids it's a lot trickier to work with. |
 |
| My best try, after about three attempts at creating a nice wing |
The formulation is indeed incredibly long lasting and smudge-proof. However, the super thick gel paired with a flimsy silicone applicator just doesn't work very well. I consider myself pretty decent at making winged liners but with this product I struggled quite a bit.
Availability:
Smashbox is available online at Sephora, Smashbox.com and in stores at Shoppers Drug Mart, Murale.
