September 2013 Wantable Makeup Box: Review and Swatches

Disclaimer: The box were provided for review.

I was quite keen on beauty subscriptions when they first came out a couple years ago because getting beauty surprises right in your mailbox every month is nothing short of magicial. But as the months went on, I slowly became bored and dissatisfied with every service I tried. I kept getting repeats, teeny samples, expired products, unwearable colors and anti-aging products I would never use.
So how does Wantable Makeup Box, a relatively new beauty subscription stand against the rest?